Just Finished Reading … Trinkets by Kirsten Smith

by Kirsten Smith
To be published by Little, Brown BFYR
on March 12, 2013

Source: e-ARC from the publisher via NetGalley for possible review. Please see my FTC disclosure to the right on the sidebar.

Connect with the author: website: Twitter.

Summary (adapted from Goodreads:) Sixteen-year-old Moe's Shoplifters Anonymous meetings are usually punctuated by the snores of an old man and the whining of the world's unhappiest housewife. Until the day that Tabitha Foster and Elodie Shaw walk in. Tabitha has just about everything she wants: money, friends, popularity, a hot boyfriend who worships her...and clearly a yen for stealing. So does Elodie, who, despite her goodie-two-shoes attitude pretty much has "klepto" written across her forehead in indelible marker. But both of them are nothing compared to Moe, a bad girl with an even worse reputation. Tabitha, Elodie, and Moe: a beauty queen, a wallflower, and a burnout -- a more unlikely trio high school has rarely seen. And yet, when Tabitha challenges them to a steal-off, so begins a strange alliance linked by the thrill of stealing and the reasons that spawn it.

My take:  It was an interesting experience to read this immediately after Dear Cassie by Lisa Burstein, which I reviewed on Saturday.  Both Trinkets and the Pretty Amy/Dear Cassie books deal with a trio of girls who get busted. All feature realistic teen characters and a lot of humor.

There are some differences, too. In Pretty Amy and Dear Cassie, we see three friends driven apart after their arrest, while in Trinkets, the girls' relationship develops after they get in trouble. While Burstein decided to devote a complete book to each character, Trinkets is the story of all three girls. There's Tabitha, the popular princess, Elodie, the shy new girl, and Moe, the girl with the home-dyed hair who hangs with the burn-outs because that way "no one effs with you."  Are you getting a Breakfast Club vibe here? Me too. Which is a good thing, as far as I'm concerned.

The book is narrated by all three girls in alternating points of view. I was initially alarmed because Elodie's chapters are in verse. While I love poetry, I've found that YA books in verse are really not for me. Luckily for me, Moe's and Tabitha's POVs are in regular prose. While I didn't love the verse, it did help me remember whose head I was in.

The three girls, who don't travel in the same social circles at school, come to know one another through the shoplifters' support group. And, of course, they discover that they actually have a lot in common. Trinkets gives each girl a quickly sketched backstory -- each has parents who fall into what I'm now officially calling the Five D's of YA Parents: Dead, Divorced, Distant, Drunk, or Distracted. Moe's parents are dead and she and her brother are being raised by an aunt. Tabitha's are unhappily married and distant and her mom has a drinking problem. Elodie's mom died and her dad is distracted by his new wife.

Trinkets has the charm and humor of a good chick flick. I picked the book up at a time when I was tired and a little grumpy and this kind of story was exactly what I needed. This book is funny -- laugh-out-loud funny in parts. The book's not squeaky-clean, reflecting the way a lot of kids really talk -- but nothing that's out of the bounds of a typical YA. And even though the book's premise and characters are familiar ones, the plot took a couple of turns and twists that I wasn't expecting. Trinkets was a fun and enjoyable read and I recommend it to readers who like realistic YA that's more glossy than gritty, with a strong dose of humor and fun.

Edited to add: After Bookworm1858's comment, I should add that yes, there is romance in the book for all three girls, and charming John Hughes-style romance at that. Tabitha has a really awful boyfriend, Moe is in love with the popular boy across the street, and Elodie is really shy and a little awkward. But to me, the girls' friendship was the central part of the story.


  1. Liking the sound of Trinkets, especially as there was no mention of boys/love interests for the girls (is that an accurate assessment?) I'm a contemporary lover who prefers glossy to gritty as well as humorous books so I think this will be a good read for me.

    1. Dang it, I can't believe I forgot to mention that yes, there is romance. But it's not an in-your-face kind of Boy Crazy romance. All the romances made me smile.

  2. Sounds like something I would love! Also this is the first review I have seen and it's a great one.

  3. Your Five D's of YA Parents is so true when it comes to YA! That's kind of a shame, though. Glad that there's a strong dose of humor :)

    Great review!

  4. Hmm this sounds interesting, I haven't heard of it. I don't usually do prose either, but glad you connected with the other.
    Brandi @ Blkosiner’s Book Blog

  5. How have I not heard of this one?? This sounds just like my kind of book (I think it's The Breakfast Club reference that sold me on it:) But I do love reading about bad girls, or even just kind of messed up good girls who make bad decisions. And the fact that it is laugh out loud funny is even better!

    And I LOVE your 5 D's of YA Parents! That is BRILLIANT. You should do a post on that topic alone with examples! Very, very clever, Jen and SO true:)

  6. Great write up; I'm really interested in this, esp with the 3 character POV. I'll keep my eye on it.

  7. I love gritty, but sometimes glossy is just the trick. PS- I have officially requested Eleanor & Park from the libs.

  8. Hmm I haven't read many books about sisters and I definitely haven't read many with all three sisters POV's. I'll have to check this one out, great review! :

  9. This sounds fabulous!! This is the first review of it I have read, but I am adding it to my TBR list.

  10. How interesting that one of the POV is in verse! I need to put this one on my list.

  11. I love books with strong female friendships, especially when they're funny. This one sounds like a lot of fun, and I like that the three voices are different. Even the verse sounds neat, as long as it blends well with the rest of the story. Too bad for absent family members, but I love your alliteration for the 5 D's! I'm with Heather. Very clever!!

  12. Ooh this one sounds so fabulous. I'm definitely going to have to check it out now. I like that all three girls are very different and I actually look forward to the verse parts since I do love novels in verse. Great review!

  13. I wish there was one book where the parents are involved. Well there is. IN Sherrilyn Kenyon YA novels The Chronicles Of Nick, his mom is always involved some how and I really like that.

    Back to your review, awesome.!

  14. This one sounds good too! I love books with good friendships in them, or at least focuses on the friendships.

  15. Chick flick charm and humor and John Hughes style romance? I definitely need to read this one! I need a book like this in my TBR for days when I just need a fun, satisfying experience. And love the 5D's of YA Parents—so funny, (and sadly, true). Awesome review, Jen!

  16. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  17. I hadn't seen this one either. It looks like it is one I would enjoy reading. I love books with humor! Thanks, Jen!


Post a Comment

Thanks so much for stopping by. I hope you will share your thoughts on this post!