Review of Beware That Girl by Teresa Toten

Beware That Girl by Teresa Toten

To be published by Delacorte BFYR on May 31, 2016

Synopsis from Goodreads: The Haves. The Have-Nots. 

Kate O’Brian appears to be a Have-Not. Her whole life has been a series of setbacks she’s had to snake her way out of—some more sinister than others. But she’s determined to change that. She’s book smart. She’s street-smart. Oh, and she’s also a masterful liar. 

As the scholarship student at the Waverly School in NYC, Kate has her work cut out for her: her plan is to climb the social ladder and land a spot at Yale. 

She’s already found her “people” among the senior class “it” girls—specifically in the cosseted, mega-wealthy yet deeply damaged Olivia Sumner. As for Olivia, she considers Kate the best friend she’s always needed, the sister she never had. 

When the handsome and whip-smart Mark Redkin joins the Waverly administration, he immediately charms his way into the faculty’s and students’ lives—becoming especially close to Olivia, a fact she’s intent on keeping to herself. It becomes increasingly obvious that Redkin poses a threat to Kate, too, in a way she can’t reveal—and can’t afford to ignore. How close can Kate and Olivia get to Mark without having to share their dark pasts?

Review of Beware That Girl by Teresa Toten

The synopsis compares this book to We Were Liars, The Girl on the Train, and Gone Girl, but as I was reading, I just got a HUGE Gossip Girl vibe. First, I'll sum up my reaction, and then for you fellow Gossip Girl fans, I will point out all the similarities.

As the synopsis suggests, Kate O'Brien has conned herself into the exclusive Waverly School, where she picks out the perfect girl to befriend: beautiful, troubled Olivia Sumner. 

In the end, both characters were sort of a conglomeration of stereotypes in search of a plot. Kate was a pathological liar: ambitious, conniving, and trying to get on the inside of the in-crowd. Kate is good at manipulation, but I didn't really understand what her end game was, except to pretend she was something she's not.  

Olivia is just as much of an enigma. She has looks and money and daddy issues, plus some big psychological problems. Throw in an attractive young school administrator with a penchant for attractive blondes, and you've got a trio of trouble....

Beware That Girl was definitely entertaining while I was reading it, but all the characters were pretty unlikeable and unrelatable. 

There was a "shocking" development near the end that wasn't really all that shocking.  The book never made it clear what all the characters were up to beyond just being messed up connivers who get in one another's way. 

I hoped this would have more psychological complexity beyond Kate's obsessive reading of the DSM manual, but in the end this became a mildly entertaining story with no real point.

For those of you who are Gossip Girl fans:

Kate O'Brien = Juliet Sharp + Ivy Dickens
Take Juliet Sharp's creepy obsession with Serena and add Ivy Dickens' wrong-side-of-the-tracks background and conniving opportunism, and you have Kate O'Brien.

Olivia Sumner = Blair Waldorf + Serena van der Woodsen
 Olivia has Blair's Ivy obsession, Serena's horrible taste in men, and both girls' daddy issues...

Beware that Girl also features:

 A Polish housekeeper-slash-confidante


Obsession with Yale

Sad/Unconventional Thanksgiving

Creepy/Age-Inappropriate Relationship

If all this sounds like your speed, I'd recommend binge-watching Gossip Girl this summer. Things got a little off-track in Season Three, but then they got right back on track again. 

If you liked Gossip Girl, Beware That Girl might give you a bit of a fix. For me, Beware That Girl's characters and plot just weren't as compelling...


  1. The cover looks like The Girl on the Train.

    Probably not a book for me...

    Karen @For What It's Worth

    1. Yeah, I don't get the comparison to that book at all.

  2. I remember reading The Gossip Girl series ages ago but right now, it just isn't my thing. Skipping this one then (such a shame because I like the cover!).

  3. hmm I have never watched gossip girls so I don't know about the comparisons but it may not be the book for from what you have said.

  4. Read a review for this one yesterday, and I must say I'm interested. I've only read Gone Girl, and watched Gossip Girl, but this looks like I may enjoy it? IDK, I just love the school setting and plotting.

  5. I haven't watched Gossip Girl. Buuuut, this doesn't really sound like my kind of book if it really has not much plot. WAH. I really need books to have a solid point or I just fall out of interest with them super fast. But at least it was mildly entertaining for you Jen! :D

  6. Sadly not a gossip girl fan, but this one sounds interesting! Sucks about the plotless plot though (if that makes sense haha) thanks for the review!

  7. Oops, the synopsis sounds like something I would love, but it doesn't seem so. I'm not a huge GG fan, so I'm not sure if I'll enjoy this one.


Post a Comment

Thanks so much for stopping by. I hope you will share your thoughts on this post!