Review of The Best Possible Answer by E. Katherine Kottsras

The Best Possible Answer by E. Katherine Kottsras

To be published by St. Martin's Griffin on November 1, 2016

Source: eARC for review

Plot Summary for The Best Possible Answer by E. Katherine Kottsras 

AP Exams – check

SAT test – check

College Application – check

Date the wrong guy and ruin everything you’ve spent your whole life working for– check

Ultra-high-achiever Viviana Rabinovich-Lowe has always had a plan—and no room to be anything less than perfect. 
But her quest for perfection comes to a screeching halt when her boyfriend leaks racy pictures of her to the entire school. 
Making matters worse, her parents are getting divorced and now her perfect family is falling apart. For the first time, Viv feels like a complete and utter failure.
Then she gets a job working at the community pool, where she meets a new group of friends who know nothing about her past. That includes Evan, a gorgeous guy who makes her want to do something she never thought she’d do again: trust. 

For the first time in her life, Viv realizes she can finally be whoever she wants. But who is that? While she tries to figure it out, she learns something they never covered in her AP courses: that it’s okay to be less than perfect, because it’s our imperfections that make us who we are. 

Review of The Best Possible Answer by E. Katherine Kottsras 

This book definitely had its moments, but also had a whole lot of plot elements and for me they didn't all work together.

It's the summer before Viviana's senior year, and she's got a plan: spend the summer at an engineering academy, SAT prepping, etc. But her crippling anxiety attacks start getting in the way. Her shifting relationships with her absent, high-achieving father and her best friend, who likes the same guy that Viviana's falling for, have her seriously off-balance.  As Viviana's plans start to crumble, she begins to question her goals, and who she wants to be.

It seems to me that would be plenty of plot for a book (and the chapter headings modeled after standardized testing were clever and funny). But then there was a WHOLE lot of other stuff. 

First, there was backstory about Viviana sending naked pictures of herself to an ex, backstory that was used as a reason for Viviana's anxiety attacks. I didn't really think this added anything to the story. Plus, it was sort of perplexing to me. 

Because it happened before the book begins, the reader isn't really sure exactly what happened or why. At the start of the book, Viviana seems like such a responsible, level-headed person, with her endless college to-do list, that taking nude pictures of herself and sending them to a guy seemed really out of character, and the book didn't really explain why she did this. 

Much later in the book she says something bizarre, like "when when I love, I love with all my heart" (and naked pictures, apparently.) This incident was also used to explain trust issues she had with the new guy, but for me that just muddled the issue that Viviana knows she's falling for a guy she knows her best friend Sammi is crushing on. Uncool!

Another big part of the plot has to do with Viviana's parents. Her mother has health issues, and her father is sort of inexplicably off in Singapore. 

Without spoilers, I think that another option to pull the plots together would have been if this storyline stayed and the SAT stuff went. 

By the end of the book, I was beginning to see that Viviana was not the level-headed person she pretended to be, that she and her father were people who liked to pretend to be very logical and then secretly go off the rails.  

Viviana with her nude pictures with one guy and then sneaking around with the guy her best friend likes rather than speaking up and saying that she likes him too. 

I think if Viviana's discovery of her father's secrets had made her reconsider some of her own choices, THAT would have been a cohesive plot (minus the anxiety and college stuff). But to me, all of these elements didn't really work together: college, sexting, anxiety, best friend romance drama, parent drama, family secrets. 

Plus there was this whole subplot about an eccentric professor that was interesting, but again, I think it might have belonged in a different book.

My favorite cover of the week, though!


  1. I do like the cover. This sounds more complicated than what I want to read right now ;). Great, honest review and I always appreciate that :)

    1. It was a lot. I liked the individual elements, but I didn't think they all fit together...

  2. That's basically how I felt about the story. It wasn't bad, but there was a lot of plot hole-esque stuff, things that didn't make sense or needed more explaining. I do think that Sammie was kind of being a brat about the whole Evan situation because it was really clear that he didn't like Sammie, he liked Vivi and that wasn't Vivi's fault at all, but she could have been up front with Sammie in the first place and said "Hey, I know him." I don't know...the whole story was kind of messy. Not unreadable by any means, but messy.

    1. Agree completely. Sammi was a little ridiculous, but Viviana needed to talk to her, not just sneak around and feel guilty about it.

  3. Ah yes, there were a lot of elements to this, some I liked and others not so much

  4. Yeah, the uptight-miss perfect- over achiever- type A girl M/C usually doesn't work for me. Sometimes I'll like it, but mostly they follow the same formula. So yeah, not really thinking thinking this is the book for me :(

  5. Oh no, I was looking forward to reading this book, but it doesn't sound like something I would like. That thing with the best friend sounds really bad.


Post a Comment

Thanks so much for stopping by. I hope you will share your thoughts on this post!